Steven Knapp, 2007-present

Stephen Joel Trachtenberg, 1988-2007

Lloyd Hartman Elliott, 1965-88

Thomas Henry Carroll, 1961-64

Cloyd Heck Marvin, 1927-59

William Mather Lewis, 1923-27

William Miller Collier, 1918-21

Charles H. Stockton, 1910-18

Charles Willis Needham, 1902-10

Benaiah L. Whitman, 1895-1900

James Clarke Welling, 1871-94

Rev. George Whitefield Samson, 1859-71

Joseph Getchell Binney, 1855-58

Joel Smith Bacon, 1843-54

Stephen Chapin, 1828-41

Rev. William Staughton, 1821-27